Burning the Public Trust: Climate Change Project Oversight Blind Spots

Oversight blind spots for corruption

Oversight blind spots that let corruption through

Fragmented, non-standard portals

Where each agency posts to its own website (often with scanned PDFs), you cannot trace the life of a contract from plan to payment. The cure is publishing end-to-end, machine-readable data using standards like OCDS and OC4IDS, with geotagged milestones and change orders. Imagine visualizing the procurement process as Plan ➔ Tender ➔ Contract ➔ Payment, each step clearly documented and accessible. (Open Contracting Partnership; CoST) (Comptroller and Auditor General of India).

Weak blacklists and poor ownership data

If sanctions aren’t published—and if companies can reincarnate with new shells—blacklists are merely a formality. Beneficial-ownership transparency and routine checks against ownership networks help close the revolving door (Open Ownership, 2021; OGP, 2023; IMF, 2025). (openownership.org)

Limited civic access and “PDF traps”

When the only “disclosure” is a grainy, unsearchable scan of a 200-page contract, citizens can’t scrutinize. Infrastructure transparency initiatives refer to these as “PDF traps” and advocate for structured data, open designs, and accessible As-Built drawings (CoST). (Inquirer.net)

Case study: India’s rural roads and drainage—quality shortfalls and audit findings

India’s massive Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) program improved rural connectivity and flood resilience. Yet performance audits by the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) consistently highlighted gaps in quality assurance, planning, and fund absorption—persistent risks for cost inflation and compromised infrastructure (CAG, 2017; 2016). For example, a school bus unable to cross a flooded road due to drainage failure illustrates how these audit findings affect daily life and safety.

What the audits found (illustrative points):

Quality assurance & monitoring gaps: In a multi-year PMGSY audit, CAG observed deficiencies in quality control, suggesting that critical tests were not consistently performed or documented, increasing the risk of substandard works (CAG, 2017) (AGUP).
Planning inconsistencies and misclassification: Roads classified as “all-weather” included stretches of cart tracks and gravel roads, thereby undermining the program’s promise. The government accepted certain findings and committed to corrective steps (CAG, Andhra Pradesh, 2014) (ag.ap.nic.in).
Unspent balances and rushed cycles: High year-end balances (ranging from 40% to 74% unspent in some years for a sampled state during 2010–13) created pressure to push tenders late in the fiscal year—a classic setup for poor competition and hurried supervision (CAG, 2016).

Why this matters for drainage and resilience:

Rural roads and drains often share corridors; compromised compaction, culvert sizing, and side-drain execution leave communities cut off or flooded when monsoon peaks. The World Bank's procurement research stresses that practices (market sounding, realistic timelines, disclosure) reduce risks more than rules on paper—a relevant lesson for PMGSY-like programs (World Bank, 2021). As a notable success, one district successfully implemented market sounding to engage with potential suppliers, resulting in competitively priced and higher-quality bids. This approach not only ensured timely project completion but also improved community resilience during monsoon seasons. Such examples highlight the potential of adopting proactive procurement strategies to achieve better outcomes.

Citizen takeaway: look for independent materials tests, culvert/bridge As-Built drawings, and geotagged photos; if these don’t exist or are only scanned, the risk of hidden defects is high (CoST/OC4IDS) (Inquirer.net).

Adapt or Perish in Climate Change: Innovative Solutions to Thrive Amid Climate Emergency for a Sustainable Future

Adapt or Perish in Climate Change: An Introduction Climate change is no longer a distant forecast spoken of in cautious scientific terms; it is the lived experience of our time. From unprecedented heatwaves across Europe and Asia , to record-breaking wildfires in North America , to the rising seas that threaten low-lying islands and coastal megacities, the signs of a planet in distress are everywhere. Each year brings new evidence that the climate emergency is not a future scenario but an unfolding reality, reshaping how we grow food, build homes, generate energy, and even imagine our collective future. The old assumptions—that we can postpone action, that incremental steps will suffice, that someone else will solve the problem—have collapsed under the weight of accelerating change. The question is no longer whether climate disruption will affect us, but how profoundly it will shape our lives and those of generations to come. This book, Adapt or Perish in Climate C...

Turning Public Data Into Public Power

Turning public data into public power Practical guide: turning public data into public power This section serves as a guide for citizens, journalists, and civil society organizations to independently verify, analyze, and advocate for greater transparency in climate and environmental projects. Treat each step as part of an iterative learning loop—ask, test, refine, and repeat. By viewing these practical actions as a continuous process—from setting baselines to publishing replication files—you can transform open data into meaningful oversight and accountability, echoing the Monitoring, Evaluation, and Learning (MEL) principles discussed earlier. Step 1 — Pin down the baseline (don’t move the goalposts). Before accepting “impact,” ask: Impact against what? For floods : historic water-level or depth maps per neighborhood; baseline water-logging days. For nature-based projects: initial canopy cover and species-site plan per plot; survival targets at 12 & 36 months. Document data ...

Youth Action and Adaptation on Climate Change: Peer Education and Campaigns

Climate education and awareness campaigns Engaging in Peer Education and Awareness Campaigns Peer education and awareness campaigns are powerful tools for empowering youth to address climate change. They allow young people to educate their peers, share ideas, and mobilize collective action. In recent years, social media has emerged as a transformative platform for these campaigns, amplifying the voices of young people and expanding their reach far beyond traditional methods. This section examines how social media has revolutionized peer education, highlighting examples of successful youth-led awareness initiatives that demonstrate the impact of these efforts. The Role of Social Media in Peer Education Social media platforms, including Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube, have become central to youth-led peer education campaigns. They offer accessible, cost-effective tools for sharing information, organizing events, and inspiring action on climate issues. Young people increasingly r...

Abbey Abramson

Search This Blog